Yo, this be Reuben. I don’t need to explain this, do I? Well, in case you dinguses don’t know what a ‘RANKED’ post is, it’s one that ranks parts of a certain category in ascending order from worst to best – thems the ropes, boi.

Now, I’m a huge Mastodon fan, as can be seen through my many mentions and pieces of high praise for the band’s work on this website, including most recently my Top Ten Bands Redux. Cheeky links aside, Mastodon are a sort of sludgy prog metal band from Atlanta in the states, made up of four talented musicians including the top-class drummer Brann Dailor and the renowned guitar-shredder Brent Hinds, who both sing along with stylistic bassist Troy Sanders. Bill Kelliher’s also there. That wasn’t a dig, he’s just a rhythm guitarist — apparently he’s a bit of a dude. They’re a band who have been growing in popularity since their 2004 breakthrough release Leviathan, with their latest release Once More ‘Round the Sun reaching 6th in US charts, they’re one of those who are destined to headline the big metal festivals like Download at some point, along with Babymetal, oddly – and hey, I have nothing against Babymetal. Anyways, let’s get into this article properly.

Leviathan (2004)

Image result for mastodon leviathan

Oooooooooh. This is a very dodgy choice, putting their most critically acclaimed and a fan favourite at the bottom of the pile. Oh well, I’m sure it’ll fend for itself down here. I’m just not quite sure about Leviathan, I don’t think its either as chunky or gloriously brutal as Remission or as well-rounded and musically impressive as their later records. It’s just some songs on the album lack enough power and the melodies for the most part aren’t quite there for me, despite the awe-inspiring first two tracks in Blood and Thunder and I Am Ahab. I mean, if the rest of the album possessed the power and drive of the first two tracks, I think it could easily be Mastodon‘s best record; but it drops off, and Brent Hinds does some vocals that don’t really fit with the rest of the music. However, it certainly has its highlights and possesses dozens of awesome riffs. Moreover, it’s Moby Dick concept gives it a powerful and unique sense, which coupled with the fuzzy riff heaven makes for an immense story.

Particular Gooduns:

Blood and Thunder

I Am Ahab

Hearts Alive

Naked Burn


Remission (2002)

Image result for remission album cover

Remission, really, is very similar to Leviathan in how it sounds, but yet it is a better album. I know it hasn’t got that same power with the concept and the story, but Remission is pure metal delight throughout. It’s a barrage of glorious riffs with brutal vocals from Troy Sanders and incredible tight beats from Brann Dailor to baffle the eardrums. It’s got a brilliant heaviness that hasn’t been matched by the band since, but it is made by the melding of that and the floating guitar licks and instrumental interludes Mastodon are known for.

Particular Gooduns:

March of the Fire Ants

Ol’e Nessie

Trampled Under Hoof




The Hunter (2011)

Image result for the hunter album cover

The home of Curl of the Burl and Black Tongue, The Hunter is one for the riff lovers. As a Mastodon album, it is the least prog-influenced and takes a leap into hard rock and alternative metal as the band attempted to reach larger audiences. It worked, because the record saw a huge increase in Mastodon album, ticket sales and all that good stuff. Popularity ain’t the important thing, though, that’s the music.

The Hunter holds the band’s cleanest and straight-up hard rock sound to date, as they concentrated a bit more on the simpler stuff. Some fans haven’t liked the record’s lighter approach, but the fantastic musicianship, catchiness, riffage and not least clean mix housed on the album are all welcome to my ears. The Hunter is an easy and highly enjoyable listen, but still with the musical flair and charm that I love so much from Mastodon. Nonetheless, it’s far from my favourite album by the band, and it features a few dud tracks.

Particular Gooduns:

Black Tongue

Curl of the Burl

The Hunter

All the Heavy Lifting

Dry Bone Valley


Blood Mountain (2006)

Image result for blood mountain mastodon

Blood Mountain is Mastodon‘s second heaviest record behind Remission. It’s the first album by the band that shakes off the sludgy, slightly doom metal-like attributes of their early works, and introduces a cleaner sound that would be further developed upon later on. Blood Mountain was an in between point between their original sound and their later more clean approach, incorporating influences from both types of their music. However, it also uses more prog influences that were later the driving force for Crack the Skye. The mix of styles makes for an interesting album, and an unforgettable listen. Although there are admittedly too much instrumental gaps and some of the problems in Leviathan can still be heard, the musicianship is incredible, with Brann Dailor and Brent Hinds at their very best, so there isn’t a dull moment. It’s a joy to hear the band at their best on their respective instruments, and that is what you get from Blood Mountain.

Little touches like the awesome cameo appearances from Cedric Bixler-Zavala, Ikey Owens (both Mars Volta members) and Josh Homme (Queens of the Stone Age frontman) also make for nice inclusions, along with the amazing surprise at the end of Pendulous Skin, to boot.

Particular Gooduns:

The Wolf is Loose

Sleeping Giant

Colony of Birchmen

This Mortal Soil

Siberian Divide


Once More ‘Round the Sun (2014)

Image result for mastodon once more round the sun

Godly album art.

I can’t stop listening to Once More ‘Round the Sun, and I don’t think I’ll ever stop. The atmosphere in this record is spot on, with an incredible sound wall across the whole thing. Brent Hinds is great as ever, and so is Brann Dailor, but the stand out on this record is Troy Sanders – on both the bass and the microphone. His super-cool laid back slap bass controls the album from peak to trough, as he delivers his most accomplished vocal performance to date. Brann Dailor’s vocals are delivered to perfection, too, carrying on that lighter feel brought from The Hunter. The melodies are the best they have ever been, as Tread Lightly, The Motherload and Ember City emphatically show with their ever memorable choruses – and even song structures, I know these songs note through note. Once More ‘Round the Sun, more than anything, possesses a deep and accomplished sound which is their loudest and most impressive to date, as the fill-heavy drums, bass tunes and guitar licks bash the eardrums apart.

It’s a damn cool record, all that holds it back from the top spot are one or two weaker tracks.

Particular Greatuns:

Tread Lightly

The Motherload

Chimes At Midnight

Asleep in the Deep

Ember City


Aunt Lisa


Crack the Skye (2009)

Image result for crack the skye

This album is special. What I would consider one of the best albums of all time, Crack the Skye is a progressive metal masterclass. It possesses the musical skill expected of Mastodon and more, as the album explores deeper prog themes. It keeps the power of Blood Mountain, but smooths the edges and gives it that something extra. It has an equally impressive sound to that of Once More ‘Round the Sun, and is house to prog metal greats ranging from Oblivion to The Czar. The record showed fans and critics alike that Mastodon could play more patient material, and didn’t need to make their music heavy to be good – something they hinted at with Blood Mountain. Jeering guitar solos and big symbols pervade through the seven masterpieces on Crack the Skye, with a giant and powerful sound wall created.

Knowing the tragic story behind the album also makes it that bit more effective, as along with songs like Oblivion being so incredible in their instrumental depth and their huge melodies, they come across as emotional too. Crack the Skye was the coming of age for Mastodon, where they refined their sound to perfection and delivered a truly great record to be enjoyed by prog and metal fans alike. They haven’t done anything better since, but based on their progress made with Once More ‘Round the Sun I’m hopeful that there will be a Mastodon album of this quality yet again.

Particular Amazinguns:



Bringing redundant opinions for scrollers everywhere,


3 thoughts on “RANKED: Mastodon Albums – Reuben

  1. Hi, I was directed here by Speedy Sailor.

    Hm, a very interesting list. I can see your point about Leviathan, though, as there particular stand-out tracks but then the rest of the album is sort of…bleh. Same with Remission. Definitely from Blood Mountain the band got a lot better at making the album fuller and better, not just with a few standout tracks.

    Of course, Crack The Skye is at the top.

    If you’d like to check out my list, view it here: https://nickkazama.wordpress.com/2017/02/11/opinion-ranking-every-mastodon-from-best-to-worst/


    Liked by 1 person

      • It wouldn’t a Mastodon album if I had to really sit and listen to the album studiously, really just taking it.

        It’s a very hard album for me to listen to because of the album’s concept (the whole wanderer being given a death sentence) as I’ve had to deal with my own personal loss in the past year.

        Saying that, I think it’s a very good album and possibly the best of their newest era since they released The Hunter…this trying to be accessible yet prog at the same time.

        I may do a re-ranking to see where Emperor of Sand fits in there.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.